Is This Any Way to Run a Democracy?
America prides itself on being the oldest continuous democracy in the world. But criticisms of the America system are widespread. Our system is tailored to narrow interests and wealthy elites. Our two parties lock out alternative voices. Our voting procedures discourage participation and lead to unrepresentative outcomes. Is this really the best way to run a democracy? Join John and Ken as they examine the philosophical underpinnings of democracy in America.
What is so good about democracy? Ken thinks democracy is the most moral form of government. Is the democracy in the United States working well? Our representatives and senators make most decisions without popular input. John claims California has much more interaction between the people and the government. Is this a good thing? Ken introduces Josh Ober, professor at Princeton. What are the best arguments for democracy? Ober thinks that democracy requires an assumption of equality to get started. John asks what is wrong with a government ruled by a group of experts? Ober counters, saying that the experts are not guaranteed to be beneficent. One of the benefits of democracy is that people will try to work out their differences. What about issues on which people cannot agree, such as abortion?
Do we have too much democracy in the US? What is allowable as to restrictions on individual freedoms and right in a democracy? If the entire population has one common religion, governing becomes easier. Isn't that good? Would a parliamentary democracy be better than the current form of democracy in the U.S.? Ober doubts that a parliamentary system would solve the problems of American democracy. What is the relationship between education and democracy? Ober warns against using education as a ticket to voting. What is the relationship between media communication and democracy? Ober thinks that one-way communication will damage democracy. Many institutions that were put in place to aid the fledgling American democracy have now gotten large and unwieldy. Are these institutions to blame for the problems here?
How can we improve our democracy? Ober says that we should push the decision-making mechanism as close to local government as we can. Ken thinks that we need a national level government to assure equality across the country. Does the electoral college diminish the democratic process? Is our two-party system limiting to democracy? Ober worries that small parties tend to be extremist. In ancient Greece, political parties were not viewed as favorable. Do we need them today?
- Amy Standen the Roving Philosophical Reporter (04:40): Amy Standen quizzes several Californians about their knowledge of propositions on California's ballot. Amy also asks how much anyone knows about the laws they vote on.
- Ian Shoales the Sixty Second Philosopher (Seek to 50:17): Ian Shoales runs through the history of the concept of democracy, from Plato to Locke to de Tocqueville.
Josiah Ober, University Center for Human Values, Princeton University
- The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
- An HTML version of Alexis de Tocqueville's Democracy in America
- James Madison's Federalist Paper No. 10, in which he argues for a republic rather than a democracy
- Plato's Republic
- Aristotle's Politics
- Isaiah Berlin's collection Liberty
- John Locke's Two Treatises Concerning Government
- Thomas Paine's Collected Writings
- Biographical work on all the founding fathers of the US Constitution entitled Founding Fathers: Brief Lives of the Framers of the United States Constitution
- Josh Ober's book Mass and Elite Democratic Athens
- Alexis de Tocqueville's Democracy in America
Get Philosophy Talk
Broadcast live on your iPhone or Android using the Public Radio Player